I’m right! You’re wrong!

Debates in church and politics can get painfully polarized, especially when participants hear only from like-minded people. Within our respective echo chambers, voices on both sides of an issue become shrill. We are tempted to demonize others who disagree.

Buildings that house the Dead Sea Scrolls in Jerusalem have architecture symbolizing such binary thinking. Underneath a white dome in the foreground are precious scrolls discovered in the desert at Qumran in the mid-twentieth century. The dome is shaped like the lid of one of the jars that stored the famous scrolls for two thousand years. Below the black wall in the background is the entrance to the underground museum.

Israel, Jerusalem, Shrine of the Book
The Shrine of the Book at the Israel Museum in Jerusalem features architecture illustrating dualistic, black-and-white theology.

This black and white architecture represents the ideology of self-described “Sons of Light” who collected the scrolls. In the late second century BC, sectarian Jews called Essenes opposed what they saw as corruption among Jewish leaders at the temple in Jerusalem. Some withdrew to monastic-like living at Qumran by the Dead Sea to await the Messiah. They expected a lengthy military confrontation between the “Sons of Light” and the “Sons of Darkness.”

Israel, Qumran, caves where scrolls were found-1
In these and other caves near to the Qumran community by the Dead Sea, Essenes hid hundreds of scrolls before the Roman army destroyed Qumran in about AD 68.

In a scriptorium at Qumran, Essenes copied books of the Bible and other literature specific to their movement. After Jews revolted against Rome in AD 66, a Roman army swept through the Jordan valley. Qumran residents apparently hid manuscripts in nearby caves for protection. Hundreds of manuscripts remained undiscovered  until 1946 and following.

Suddenly in the modern era scholars had manuscripts of the bible nearly a thousand years older than anything previously available. The scrolls revealed that the Old Testament text we have today is close to what Jews knew in Jesus’ day. Scribes over a millennium had done their copy work well.

Some writing specific to the Qumran community is polarizing and dualistic. The famous War Scroll  begins, “The first attack of the Sons of Light shall be undertaken against the forces of the Sons of Darkness, the army of Belial. . .” Forty years of warfare will follow, and the Sons of Light will win. A charter for the Qumran community declares that “all who are not reckoned as belonging to [God’s] covenant must be separated out, along with everything they possess.”

Qumran 3
This map shows how close Qumran was to “Bethany beyond the Jordan” where John baptized Jesus (John 1:28). It is possible that Qumran somehow influenced the thinking of John.

John the Baptist probably baptized Jesus at Bethany beyond the Jordan—within sight of Qumran on a clear day. He, too, had withdrawn from Jerusalem and had an adversarial attitude toward much that happened there. His theology sounds polarizing (“You brood of vipers!”).

Jesus called himself the “light of the world.” But he fraternized with fisher folk, Pharisees, lepers, snobs, poor people, and Roman soldiers. He taught followers to be light in the world, not light withdrawn into an enclave of like-minded people.

It is possible to have strong convictions about what it means to walk in the light and still relate in loving and respectful ways with others who see things differently.

© 2014 J. Nelson Kraybill *******************************************    IMG_0417

Join me on a journey to the Holy Land! See: From Nazareth to Rome: Holy Land, Empire and Global Mission, with Pastor Nelson Kraybill – November 3-15, 2014

See also: Holy Land (Jordan, Israel & Palestine) with Pastor Nelson Kraybill – November 5-16, 2015

I invite you to enter your email address in the designated box at the edge of this webpage (if you have not already subscribed), and click Follow. You’ll get a notice every three weeks when I put up a new blog post.

2 Comments Add yours

  1. Dorothy Cutrell says:

    This is a highly interesting piece. I’ve often wondered what the hiding place of the old scrolls looked like, and how they could have remained hidden for such a long time, so I loved the photo of the caves. Also new to me was the dualistic nature of the beliefs recorded in these scrolls. THANKS for this.


  2. Ruben R. Chupp says:


    Your final paragraph (in bold print), given America’s current divisive cultural milieu, was timely an insightful. The same is true for us Mennos, as we continue conversations around issues of sexuality. May those of us who name following Jesus as our first and primary allegiance allow that reality to season and flavor all our relationships: especially where dissonance and variance are present. rrc


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s